Italy Fines Meta €805 Million Over Facebook's Android Gallery Access Without Explicit Consent
Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, has fined Meta €805 million for allowing Facebook's Android app to access users' photo and video galleries without explicit consent, a feature enabled by default.
Intelligence analysis by Gemini 2.5 Flash

The Garante found that Facebook for Android accessed Italian users' galleries and metadata via a default-on feature, violating privacy rules requiring free and informed consent. Meta plans to appeal the "disproportionate" fine and has been ordered to disable the feature by default and seek specific consent.
Imagine your phone is like your private diary. Facebook was peeking into your photo album, suggesting pictures for you to share, without clearly asking if that was okay first. Italy's privacy police said that's not allowed and gave Facebook a huge fine, telling them they must ask nicely and clearly before looking at your private stuff.
Analysis
Garante
Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, has issued a significant fine against Meta, totaling €805 million, following an investigation into Facebook's Android application. The authority's findings centered on a feature that suggested photos and videos from users' phone galleries for posting, which was enabled by default. This default setting allowed the app to access Italian users' photos, videos, and associated metadata without their explicit and informed consent, a clear violation of established privacy regulations.
The Garante's order mandates that Meta must, within 60 days, switch off this gallery access feature by default, even for users who had previously granted permission. Furthermore, the company is required to request separate, specific consent for this feature, clearly explaining its purpose, its access to the gallery, and how users can disable it. Meta must also report its progress to the authority within 30 days and its completed measures within 90 days, with a strict penalty that the feature cannot be re-enabled for non-consenting users if the 60-day deadline is missed.
€805 Million
The substantial €805 million fine imposed on Meta represents approximately 0.47% of the company's global revenue, highlighting the severity with which the Italian authority views the privacy breach. In determining the penalty, the Garante considered several aggravating factors, including the large number of affected individuals—estimated at around 20 million Android users in Italy—and the prolonged duration of the breach, which has been ongoing since 2023. The authority noted that the breach continues for users who have not updated the app or who had already granted the broad permission.
Additional factors contributing to the fine's magnitude included a previous 2019 decision against Meta and the company's limited cooperation during the investigation. While Meta did implement some changes after the initial complaint, these were deemed late and insufficient, primarily benefiting only those users who updated the app. Meta has publicly stated its intention to appeal the fine, calling it "disproportionate," arguing that the feature only operates after users grant device-level permission, which they can modify at any time.
Article 122
The legal basis for the Garante's decision is Article 122 of Italy's Privacy Code, which transposes the European Union's ePrivacy Directive into Italian law. This specific article treats a user's phone as an integral part of their private life, stipulating that any access to the data stored on the device requires free and informed consent. Crucially, this requirement applies regardless of whether the data is subsequently transmitted elsewhere or if any direct harm results from the access itself. The authority emphasized that a single, broad permission covering multiple app functions with different purposes does not constitute valid consent for specific features like gallery suggestions.
Meta's argument that Ireland's data protection authority should handle the case was rejected by the Garante, as ePrivacy rules do not include a "one-stop-shop" mechanism, allowing national authorities to act independently on such matters. The investigation, initiated in July 2025 following a complaint from the Bolzano consumer protection group Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti, included a thorough technical analysis by the authority. The probe did not, however, examine whether gallery content was used for AI model training, a claim Meta denies, though a newer cloud-processing feature may be subject to future scrutiny.
Key points
- Italy's Garante fined Meta €805 million for Facebook's Android app accessing user galleries without explicit consent.
- The feature, which suggested photos and videos for posting, was enabled by default, violating EU ePrivacy Directive rules.
- Meta has 60 days to disable the feature by default and request separate, specific consent from all users.
- The fine's calculation considered 20 million affected Italian Android users, the breach's duration since 2023, and Meta's limited cooperation.
- Meta plans to appeal the fine, calling it "disproportionate," while the Garante rejected Meta's argument for Irish DPA jurisdiction.
This ruling could lead to greater transparency and control for users over their personal data on mobile applications, forcing tech companies to adopt clearer, more granular consent mechanisms. It may also encourage other regulatory bodies to take similar decisive action against broad data access practices.
Meta's planned appeal could prolong the resolution of this issue, potentially delaying the implementation of stricter privacy controls for users. There's also a risk that other apps might continue similar practices until directly challenged, leaving many users' data vulnerable.


